Question
2-5

Auto Claims Representative

12/8/2025

The Auto Claims Representative will investigate, evaluate, negotiate, and resolve auto insurance claims. This role involves handling high volume, low-to-moderate complexity claims while ensuring customer service excellence.

Salary

56240 - 77330 USD

Working Hours

40 hours/week

Company Size

51-200 employees

Language

English

Visa Sponsorship

No

About The Company
Founded on June 27, 1881; Michigan Millers has been providing quality property and casualty insurance through a network of independent agents to individuals, families and businesses for over 130 years. The company currently operates in Michigan and New York.
About the Role

Description

  

Who are we?

Michigan Millers Mutual Insurance Company, an affiliate of Western National Mutual Insurance, is a mutual insurance company, rated A (Excellent) by A.M. Best, with over 140 years of experience serving policyholders' property-and-casualty insurance needs across multiple regions in the United States. We believe in striving for growth without sacrifice and know that our culture creates and cultivates happy and dedicated employees, which we believe gives us the ability to deliver the highest level of customer service.


The core values for Michigan Millers and Western National Insurance, Connectiveness – Accountability – Empowerment are incorporated into all that we do. Our workplace culture encourages employees to seek out learning opportunities and to strive for growth and development in the insurance industry.


We understand the importance of a positive work community and a healthy workplace environment when striving for organizational success. Our emphasis on internal growth and maintaining healthy team relationships translates into external growth and building sustainable customer relationships.


Does this opportunity interest you?

Michigan Millers Mutual Insurance Company is seeking an Auto Claims Representative to join our team! 


The individual in this role will have the opportunity to investigate, evaluate, negotiate, and resolve auto insurance claims. 


What are the responsibilities and opportunities of this role?

  • Handles high volume, low-to-moderate complexity claims within settlement authority.
  • Ensures customer service excellence.
  • Investigates and reviews policy forms, facts, and documents that are related to claims to make appropriate decisions on claims resolutions.
  • Establishes and reviews proper reserves for each claim based upon thorough investigation, evaluation, and experience while maintaining appropriate reports to ensure the current statuses of claims is clearly documented at all times.
  • Provides direction to outside resources.
  • Performs duties and activities covered by specific instructions, standard practices, and established procedures that generally require some interpretation.
  • Gathers input and makes recommendations to solve problems of moderate complexity.
  • Deals with moderately complex problems that must be broken down into manageable pieces.
  • Sees relationships between problem components and prioritizes them.
  • Utilizes knowledge, experience, and available resources to find solutions.
  • Participates in development of improvements and helps implement changes.
  • Maintains regular contact with customers (e.g., policyholders, claimants, agents) as well as regular contact with employees across the organization and outside vendors.
  • Travels for field work as required.
  • Performs special projects and other duties as assigned.

Requirements

  

What are the must-have qualifications for a candidate?

  • Understanding of industry practices, standards, and claims concepts.
  • Prior claims experience.
  • Ability to multitask and solve problems.
  • Proficient oral and written communication skills.
  • Bachelor’s degree or equivalent related experience.

What will our ideal candidate have?

  • Negotiation and relationship-building skills.
  • Analytical with ability to exercise sound business judgment.
  • Strong time management skills. 
  • Proficient use of various core systems, office and computer equipment, and software packages.
  • Bachelor’s degree or equivalent related experience.
  • Working toward AIC or AINS certification is preferred.

Compensation overview

The targeted hiring range for this role is $56,240 - $77,330, annually. However, the base pay offered may vary depending on the job-related knowledge, skills, credentials, and experience of each candidate, as well as other factors such as the scope and location of the role. Candidates looking for compensation outside of the posted range are encouraged to apply and will be considered based on their individual qualifications and / or may be considered for other positions.


Culture and Total Rewards

We offer full-time employees a significant Total Rewards Package, including:

  • Medical insurance options and other standard employee benefits, including dental insurance, vision benefits, life insurance, and more!
  • Health Savings Accounts (HSA) and Flexible Spending Accounts (FSA)
  • 401(k) Plan (plus company match)
  • Time Off - including vacation, volunteer, and holiday pay
  • Paid Parental Leave
  • Bonus opportunities
  • Tuition assistance
  • Wellness Program - including an onsite fitness studio

Michigan Millers and Western National Insurance believe in supporting the balance between work and life by providing a flexible work environment, which includes a variety of hybrid work arrangements designed to balance individual, job, department, and company needs. 


Applicants must be authorized to work for any employer in the U.S. We are unable to sponsor or take over sponsorship of an employment Visa at this time.


Michigan Millers provides equal employment opportunities to all employees and applicants for employment and prohibits discrimination and harassment of any type without regard to race, color, religion, age, sex, national origin, disability status, genetics, protected veteran status, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, or any other characteristic protected by federal, state, or local laws.

Key Skills
Claims ExperienceCustomer ServiceInvestigationNegotiationAnalytical SkillsProblem SolvingTime ManagementCommunication SkillsRelationship BuildingMultitaskingBusiness JudgmentCore Systems ProficiencyOffice Equipment ProficiencySoftware ProficiencyAIC CertificationAINS Certification
Categories
Customer Service & SupportFinance & AccountingAdministrativeManagement & Leadership
Benefits
Medical InsuranceDental InsuranceVision BenefitsLife InsuranceHealth Savings AccountsFlexible Spending Accounts401(k) PlanPaid Time OffPaid Parental LeaveBonus OpportunitiesTuition AssistanceWellness Program
Apply Now

Please let Michigan Millers Mutual Insurance Company know you found this job on PrepPal. This helps us grow!

Apply Now
Get Ready for the Interview!

Do you know that we have special program that includes "Interview questions that asked by Michigan Millers Mutual Insurance Company?"

Elevate your application

Generate a resume, cover letter, or prepare with our AI mock interviewer tailored to this job's requirements.