Question
10+

Payroll Administrator

2/19/2026

The Payroll Administrator manages and executes biweekly payroll operations, ensuring wage payments, withholdings, and compliance with all federal, state, and local tax codes. Key duties also involve providing user support, developing training, resolving payroll inquiries, processing garnishments, and preparing necessary reports and reconciliations.

Salary

80000 - 95000 USD

Working Hours

40 hours/week

Company Size

1,001-5,000 employees

Language

English

Visa Sponsorship

No

About The Company
We're an inclusive organization of men, women and children joined together by a shared commitment to nurturing the potential of kids, promoting healthy living and fostering a sense of social responsibility. We know that lasting personal and social change comes about when we all work together. That’s why, at the Y, strengthening community is our cause. Every day, we work side-by-side with our neighbors to make sure that everyone, regardless of age, income or background, has the opportunity to learn, grow and thrive. We have 5 facilities throughout Northern New Jersey: East Orange YMCA South Mountain YMCA Sussex County YMCA West Essex YMCA New Milford YMCA Program Center/Greater Bergen County YMCA And 2 Sleep-away camps: Fairview Lake YMCA Camps in Stillwater, NJ Lake in the Woods in Blairstown, NJ Camp Michikamau in Southfields, NY In addition, we operate 3 Early Learning Child Care Centers: East Orange YMCA, West Essex YMCA Peanut Shell, and South Mountain YMCA. Established in 1885, the Metropolitan YMCA of the Oranges in New Jersey, serves more than 55,000 individuals, including 35,000+ members, and provides nearly $2.8 million in direct and indirect financial assistance yearly.
About the Role

Description

  We are an all - inclusive organization joined together by a shared commitment to nurturing the potential of kids, promoting healthy living and fostering a sense of social responsibility. As a growing, mission focused, and future-oriented association of YMCAs, the Metro YMCA of the Oranges has an exciting opportunity for a highly motivated, mission-driven, candidate to join our team.   We are currently seeking a dedicated and motivated Payroll Administrator to join our team. The Payroll Accountant is a key member of the Finance team. Key responsibilities include the administration of payroll. This includes, but is not limited to providing solutions and support for managing and executing biweekly payroll operations, ensure compliance with federal, state and local tax codes and legal regulations are met; and serving as a key liaison with leadership, managers and employees. 

Requirements

 **CANDIDATE MUST BE NJ RESIDENT**

Essential Functions:

  • Manages and executes biweekly payroll operations, ensuring proper payment of wages and withholdings as well as compliance with federal, state, and local tax codes.
  • Provides outstanding user support for Association leadership, managers and employees.
  • Develops and implements training for system users; ensures that colleagues are educated and prepared to fulfill their payroll responsibilities.
  • Responds to a variety of payroll-related inquires and resolves concerns and discrepancies, regularly monitoring manager requests.
  • Reviews and processes all garnishment orders and levies, ensuring compliance with garnishment regulations.
  • Prepares associated reports by researching, compiling and analyzing data and performing monthly and annual reconciliations.
  • Guides policy and procedure development to ensure effective, transparent, and accurate payroll cycles.
  • Develops and documents formal payroll procedures to support changes in regulations and policy. Ensure ongoing procedural and transactional adherence to legal regulations, policy, and procedures.
  • Performs periodic internal audits of various payroll and ancillary functions; prepares materials for internal and external audits.
  • Works collaboratively with Human Resources team.
  • Works collaboratively with accounting team to ensure timely and accurate reconciliations and the accuracy of payroll reporting in relations to general ledger accounts.
  • Reviews, verifies, and maintains time and attendance records in the HRIS system. Conducts regular audits of time and attendance records to ensure accuracy and compliance with policy and existing and changing regulatory requirements, including statutory requirements around sick leave and wage and hour administration.
  • Coordinates the set-up and termination of benefit plan deductions, contributions and payouts.
  • Reviews benefit plan transactions to ensure the correct tax processing of employee fringe benefits and application of appropriate withholding and reporting procedures.
  • Coordinate enrollment and eligibility for benefits during onboarding, open enrollment, and qualifying life events.
  • Serve as a liaison between employees and benefit providers to resolve issues and answer questions.
  • Ensure compliance with federal and state regulations (e.g., ERISA, HIPAA, COBRA, ACA).
  • Maintain accurate records of employee benefits data in HRIS or payroll systems.
  • Analyze benefits usage and costs to support budgeting and strategic planning.
  • Develop and distribute communications about benefits offerings, changes, and deadlines.
  • Support audits and reporting for internal reviews and external regulatory requirements. 
  • Provide training and guidance to HR staff and managers on benefits-related processes.
  • Identifies areas for improvement in both processes and systems; continuously researches best practices and new developments in payroll management and administration.
  • Performs such other job-related duties as may be periodically assigned.

Workplace Competencies:

  • Strong interpersonal skills
  • Self-starer
  • Must have the ability to work independently in a remote environment
  • Excellent written and verbal communication
  • Ability to troubleshoot and problem solve
  • Attention to detail
  • Ability to manage and train employees

Qualifications:

  • Bachelor’s degree in Accounting, Finance or Business preferred or equivalent experience.
  • Eight (8+) plus years of demonstrated experience of Payroll Administration in a complex, multi-state organization.
  • Experience with operating software and providing support for payroll administration.
  • Demonstrated understanding of HR/Payroll management, ability in streamlining processes and data analysis.
  • Strong written and oral communication skills, including the ability to relate to and communicate with users at all levels of the organization in a positive, effective manner.
  • Advanced experience in Excel skills (e.g. indexing/Vlookup, pivot tables, filters, tables)
  • Ability to train non-technical users in technical topics.
  • Ability to work independently and in collaboration with others
  • Must be detail-oriented and have strong organizational skills.
  • Experience with Paylocity and/or Dayforce

Benefits:

 We offer a competitive compensation and benefits package, which includes medical, prescription, dental, and vision coverage. We also offer generous paid time off (PTO), paid sick leave, paid holidays, a legal plan, long-term disability, life insurance, 12% retirement benefits upon eligibility, a 403 (b) plan, an employee assistance program, professional development opportunities. Full-time employees may be eligible for the Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program. 

Key Skills
Payroll AdministrationPayroll OperationsTax ComplianceUser SupportGarnishment ProcessingData AnalysisPolicy DevelopmentInternal AuditsHRIS System ManagementTime And Attendance AuditingBenefit Plan CoordinationERISA ComplianceHIPAA ComplianceCOBRA ComplianceACA ComplianceExcel
Categories
Finance & AccountingHuman ResourcesAdministrative
Benefits
MedicalPrescriptionDentalVisionPaid Time OffPaid Sick LeavePaid HolidaysLegal PlanLong-term DisabilityLife InsuranceRetirement Benefits403(b) PlanEmployee Assistance ProgramProfessional Development Opportunities
Apply Now

Please let Metropolitan YMCA of the Oranges Inc know you found this job on InterviewPal. This helps us grow!

Apply Now
Prepare for Your Interview

We scan and aggregate real interview questions reported by candidates across thousands of companies. This role already has a tailored question set waiting for you.

Elevate your application

Generate a resume, cover letter, or prepare with our AI mock interviewer tailored to this job's requirements.