Customer Service Manager I

3/23/2026

The Customer Service Manager is responsible for leading the team to ensure an exceptional customer and team member experience, managing risk, and supporting growth. This includes actively coaching staff, resolving customer issues tactfully, and ensuring compliance with all policies and regulations.

Working Hours

40 hours/week

Company Size

201-500 employees

Language

English

Visa Sponsorship

About The Company

Bank Five Nine is a full-service, independent, community bank that has served southeast Wisconsin since 1859. We enjoy long, quiet walks on the beach, puppies and romantic dinners. Nah, we're too old for all that, but we're still pretty cool, and we do actually love puppies. As a community bank, we make it a priority to give back to the customers and communities we serve through charitable giving and volunteer opportunities. We have 14 full service branches throughout Ozaukee, Washington, Waukesha and Milwaukee counties, and several loan offices in Wisconsin, Illinois, and Minnesota. Member FDIC -- Equal Housing Lender -- SBA Preferred Lender -- Bank Five Nine NMLS #: 410817 --- Milwaukee Journal Sentinel’s Top 100 Workplaces in 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 and 2024. Named as a 'Best Bank To Work' For by American Banker! --- Never disclose any financial information on LinkedIn. We are not responsible for the privacy and security policies or practices of LinkedIn. --- CONTACT US AT: (888) 569-9909 | www.bankfivenine.com

About the Role

Do you have a passion for developing employees and a sharp attention to detail? If you are a combination of those skills, we have an exciting Customer Service Manager opportunity you may want to consider.

As a Customer Service Manager, you're responsible for leading the team to ensure an exceptional customer and team member experience, manage risk, and support growth. As a leader, you will coach, motivate and develop your team of direct reports to achieve their full potential while complying with all policies and procedures.

This position is for our East Brookfield branch.

Essential Functions:

The Customer Service Manager responsibilities include:

Actively coaches staff and ensures the transfer of learning necessary for employee development and engagement.
Leads by example and helps to create a positive environment.
Assists in resolving customer issues in a tactful, effective manner and explains Bank Five Nine policies.
Ensures the staff delivers distinctive customer service.
Works to resolve internal and external customer issues promptly and courteously.
Ensures staff complies with established standards and regulations.
Resolves audit exceptions in a timely manner on an as needed basis.

The Customer Service Manager is a role model for our employees and customers and consistently reflects the Bank Five Nine brand.

Must Haves:

High school diploma or G.E.D.
At least 1+ year of experience in a retail banking environment
Basic keyboarding skills and the ability to navigate in a Windows environment

Preferred to Have:

Bachelors degree.
Coaching/training experience.
Experience with supervision or leadership of retail banking activities.
Audit/compliance expertise.
New accounts experience.

Why Bank Five Nine:

We’ve been in business over 166 years, and we’re just getting started! Bank Five Nine is on a mission to make lives better for the Wisconsin communities that we have been honored to serve since 1859! We’re excited to be named a Top Place to Work for 16 years in a row and proud to be a place that people love to come to work every day.

We are an Equal Opportunity Employer. We are committed to the full inclusion of all qualified individuals

Key Skills

CoachingEmployee DevelopmentAttention To DetailCustomer ServiceRisk ManagementLeadershipMotivationPolicy ComplianceIssue ResolutionKeyboardingWindows Navigation